A patent is not an invention. It is a series of legal promises. Each claim says, in effect: Before this priority date, the world did not already have this exact combination of features.
The searcher’s first job is to find the most vulnerable promise to attack.
Start With the Patent Owner’s Weakest Promise
Don’t start by patent searching.
Start by identifying what evidence would make the patent owner uncomfortable.
Some claims are general and some are very specific. Some are technically impressive whilst others are legally vulnerable. You might have a claim that includes promises such as a wearable biosensor, wireless communication, detection of an abnormal rhythm and alerting the user.
The searcher need to check if these have been disclosed in the prior art before the patent priority date.
A paper discussing heart rate monitoring, a product manual describing a wearable device or a patent disclosing a communication module is not enough.
The searcher must identify where each limitation appears in the prior art, or explain why a person skilled in the art would have combined the references to arrive at the claimed invention.
Claim. Evidence. Story.
Every strong invalidity search connects three things: what the patent claims, what the prior art disclosed, and why that evidence makes the claim vulnerable.
The objective is not about finding lots of evidence. It’s about finding the right evidence. The aim is to find and map out evidence which can provide a credible invalidity analysis for specific claims through patent claim analysis.
This patent invalidity search guide explains how to conduct a patent invalidity search methodically: how to identify vulnerable claims, locate and evaluate prior art, build invalidity claim charts, assess anticipation vs obviousness, and turn search findings into a defensible invalidity analysis for patent invalidation.
What Is a Patent Invalidity Search?
A patent invalidity search (sometimes referred to as a validity or patent invalidation search) is a prior art search for invalidity: a review into publicly available information prior to the relevant filing or priority date of the patent to uncover any references that may invalidate one or more claims.
It is not simply a search for an exact match.
A strong invalidity case can be based on single reference if it fully covers all the claim limitations or a set of references which would make the invention obvious to a person skilled in relevant field.
The searcher’s task is to identify the evidence, map it to the claim, and explain how it relates to the claims. Determining whether a claim is invalid, unenforceable or susceptible in a particular jurisdiction will require the assistance of qualified patent counsel and jurisdiction specific legal analysis.
What Makes a Patent Invalid? How to Invalidate a Patent
Before you search, understand is what you are trying to prove. The rules will vary between countries, but these are the main grounds for patent invalidity.
- Lacks novelty: One older document clearly describes all aspects of the claim.
- Lacks inventiveness: A person skilled in the art would have arrived at the claim by combining prior art. This is the most common reason and usually requires two or three documents.
- Lack of sufficient disclosure: The patent does not describe the invention in enough detail.
- Added matter: Changes were made to the claims during examination which include something not described in the original application.
- Unclear claims: The wording of the claim is too vague to know where the claim ends.
- Not patentable subject matter: In some countries, claims on abstract concepts or natural phenomena are not allowed
The first two reasons will be proven using prior art so it is the main focus of your patent invalidation search. The other reasons will support your case. Even if a document does not cover all aspects of a claim, it will still be useful as it can be used as half of an obviousness argument.
When Is an Invalidity Search Needed?
Invalidity searches are commonly used in the following scenarios:
- Patent litigation: To defend against a claim of infringement by providing prior art, including invalidity contentions, to invalidate the patent in question.
- Inter partes review (IPR) or patent opposition search: To provide evidence to support a formal validity process in a patent office or tribunal.
- Licensing negotiations: To help determine whether the licensor’s patent is really strong before paying royalties
- Acquisitions and investment: To determine how strong the patent portfolio is.
- Competitive intelligence: To check if a competitors’ patent will prevent your product roadmap.
- Post-grant portfolio review: Patent owners carried out search on their own patents to identify any weak claims.
- Cease-and-desist responses: The recipient of the infringement notice may investigate the possibility of whether the asserted patent can be invalidated.
How to Conduct a Patent Invalidity Search: A Step-by-Step Process
A reliable invalidity search process requires an understanding of the patent, identification of the relevant claims, an invalidity search strategy, and analysis of the information. Furthermore, prior art must be mapped to each element of the claims.
A practical approach of patent invalidity search steps is as follows:
Step 1: Understand the Target Patent
First the technical aspects of the patent, and scope of protection, by reading through the whole document.
Pay particular attention to Title, Abstract, Technical Field, Background, Description, Drawings and Embodiments. Review both independent and dependent claims, as well as the filing, publication and priority date. Patent family information and prosecution history (including any amendments) will also help you provide useful context.
It is important to understand the claims of the patent as this is what you are challenging.
For example, if the patent is called “Advanced Battery Cooling System”, the independent claim can be direct to a particular channel arrangement, coolant composition and sensor configuration. If you were to search using only the title you would miss any references that mention these technical details which uses different terminology.
Step 2: Establish the Relevant Filing and Priority Dates
Before searching for priority date prior art, identify the relevant legal date for each claim.
Check the earliest claimed priority date; the date the application was filed and its publication date. Also examines continuation/divisional application information, any priority claims and their validity. Also check whether each claim has a different priority date.
There may be cases where a patent claims priority from an earlier application. However, not all claims will have the benefit of this priority date.
For example, if an application claims priority from a 2018 application but a new technical feature is introduced in a 2020 continuation (or later) application, this feature may not have the benefit of the priority date.
Step 3: Break the Claims into Individual Technical Elements
Once the relevant claims have been identified, break it down into 4 individual elements. This is called claim charting, claim element analysis or patent claim analysis. For example:
Consider a hypothetical claim:
“A battery cooling system comprising a plurality of parallel cooling channels, a temperature sensor positioned near the battery cells, and a controller configured to regulate coolant flow based on temperature measurements.”
This claim can be broken down into 4 elements:
- A battery cooling system
- Multiple parallel cooling channels
- A temperature sensor positioned near to the battery cells
- A controller to regulates the coolant flow according to the temperature measurements.
Each of these elements can be used as search terms. This approach will help to identify alternative terminology, technical equivalents and references that disclose the elements of the claim that may not apparent from reading the patent’s title or abstract.
This can then be used as a base to compare prior art against the complete claim.
Step 4: Comprehensive Invalidity Search Strategy
A comprehensive search strategy will include a variety of methods, such as semantic patent search and AI patent invalidity search, to locate relevant prior art including documents which uses different terminology to find relevant patent.
- Keyword and Boolean search: A keyword search using technical terms, synonyms, acronyms and Boolean operators (AND, OR, NOT) to locate relevant documents. For example: (“battery cooling” OR “battery thermal management”) AND (“parallel channels” OR “coolant passages”).
- Classification search: Using IPC and CPC classification search to search for patents in the relevant technical field.
- Citation search (forward and backward citation search): Backward and forward citations can be searched to locate relevant disclosures. Forward citations published after the relevant date are not automatically prior art.
- Inventor & Assignee search: Search for publications by the inventors of the patent, their previous employers and companies working in the same technical field.
Step 5: Search Multiple Patent and Non-Patent Databases
A comprehensive invalidity search should cover multiple patent and non-patent literature databases. Relying on a single platform among patent invalidity search tools may leave important technical disclosures undiscovered.
| Database category | Examples |
|---|---|
| Patent databases (free patent search tools) | Google Patents, Espacenet, WIPO PATENTSCOPE, USPTO Patent Public Search |
| Patent registers | EPO European Patent Register |
| Scientific literature | Google Scholar, PubMed, IEEE Xplore, ScienceDirect, SpringerLink |
| Other sources | Crossref, institutional and university repositories |
The selection of databases should reflect the technology involved. For example, a pharmaceutical invalidity search may require extensive examination of clinical and scientific literature, whereas a semiconductor search may benefit from conference papers, engineering publications and technical standards.
No single database should be assumed to provide complete coverage of all potentially relevant disclosures.
Step 6: Identify and Prioritise Relevant References
There may be hundreds or even thousands of search results. Each reference should be analysed to determine how technically relevant and legally relevant they are.
A practical way to prioritise references is to classify them into three groups:
- High relevance: References which include many of the key elements of the claim or all of the claimed combination.
- Medium relevance: References which include some important technical features but require further analysis or other references.
- Low relevance: References which only include general terms or talk about the general area of technology.
This will help to ensure that detailed analysis is performed on the most promising documents.
Step 7: Conduct Detailed Claim-to-Prior-Art Mapping
Once you have found the relevant references, compare them to the individual claim limitations of the patent you are analysing. An invalidity claim chart can be used to identify which claim features are being disclosed, where they are disclosed, whether explicitly or implicitly and what is not being disclosed.
In order to determine if something is novel you will want to understand if one qualifying reference discloses all of the claim features. If you are looking at obviousness/inventive step you may need to look at a number of references. You will need to consider the technical relationship between the references, what a person skilled in the art would know and why they would be combined. You will also want to understand if the combination of features would have been technically predictable.
This cannot be done by simply looking at a similarity score.
Step 8: Verify the Evidence and Publication Dates
Not all technically relevant documents will be legally relevant prior art.
The analyst should consider:
- Publication date of the document.
- Whether the document was publicly available.
- How it relates to the relevant filing/priority date.
- Whether the document is an original disclosure or a later reproduction.
- Whether the technically relevant information was actually included in the publicly available version.
For online documents, web archives and dated records may be required.
With respect to patent documents, it is important to bear in mind that there will be a filing date and a publication date. If an earlier filed patent application is published later, then in some jurisdictions this may be given special status. However, these rules will vary between jurisdictions.
Step 9: Prepare a Patent Invalidity Search Report
The final report should convert the search findings into a clear, evidence-based assessment. A useful invalidity search report should cover five key areas:
- Patent details: Target patent, claims and relevant priority dates.
- Search methodology: Databases, keywords, classifications and search strategies.
- Prior-art evidence: Identified references, publication dates and bibliographic information.
- Technical analysis: Claim charts, novelty concerns and inventive-step arguments.
- Conclusions and next steps: Limitations, assumptions, evidence gaps and recommendations for further investigation or legal review.
The report should distinguish between confirmed technical disclosures, potential invalidity arguments and issues requiring additional legal analysis.
A well-prepared report should allow a patent attorney or in-house IP team to understand not only which documents were identified but also why those documents matter.
Common Mistakes to Avoid When Conducting Patent Invalidity Search
-
Searching Only for Identical Inventions
Many invalidity searches fail due to the team focussing on finding one references which covers all aspects of the claim. In reality, many strong cases built on combinations of multiple references and a good anticipation vs obviousness analysis.
-
Not searching Non-Patent Literature (NPL)
Whilst searching patent databases are essential, many relevant documents can also be found in product manuals, academic articles, standards, conference materials, archived web pages and public demonstrations.
-
Searching by using Only One Keyword Set
Often prior art will use different terminology used from the patent. If you do not search with different variations you may miss the most damaging references. Using semantic patent search, synonyms, classifications and citations will help to avoid this risk.
-
Incorrect priority date
The document must be prior to the relevant priority date. In patent families it can get complicated with continuations/divisionals and foreign equivalents. Check that you have the correct effective date for each challenged claim.
-
Overlooking Claim Amendments
During prosecution claim amendments can narrow or change the scope of the claim. A prior art reference which was not relevant to the original claim could now be very relevant after amendment, or vice versa.
-
Not focusing on the claims
The reference may disclose similar technology but may not disclose or suggest all the limitations of the claim. The analysis must be based on the claims not topic-specific.
-
Not keeping evidence
When dealing with litigation sensitive issues it is important to keep evidence. Take screenshots of the searches conducted in databases, save documents, archive web pages, keep metadata and ensure that you know how you found each reference.
Final thoughts
A patent invalidity search will provide evidence of whether your patent is valid. To get the best results, you should have a clear objective, a specific date and reasons for why each document matters. It is also important to start searching early, search outside of patents and test your case.
Ingenious e-Brain, perform invalidity and validity searches for law firms and corporate IP teams. We use a combination of patent, non-patent and multilingual sources to provide claim by claim reporting built for legal use.
Whether you are currently being accused of infringement, looking to investigate a blocking patent held by a competitor or just preparing for litigation. Our professional patent invalidity search services will typically provide you with:
- Access to global patent and non-patent databases.
- Researchers with experience in finding and analysing prior art to specific patent claim language.
- A defendable and legal ready patent invalidity search report.
Our professional invalidity search services will ensure you have a thorough search to find any hidden prior art. For more information on how our ingenious e-brain expert teams can help with your case please visit our patent invalidity search service page.
FAQ:-
How is a patent invalidity search different from a freedom to operate search?
A freedom to operate search asks whether your product infringes someone’s patent. A patent invalidity search asks whether that patent should exist at all. A patentability search is a third kind among the types of patent searches: it checks whether your own invention is new enough to patent. In a dispute, the first two often run side by side.
How long does an invalidity search take?
A focused search on a few claims in a mature field can take a couple of weeks. A large family across several countries takes longer. In practice, the procedural deadline often sets the pace, not the search.
How much does a patent invalidity search cost?
Invalidity search cost follows five things: the number of claims, the number of jurisdictions, the volume of non patent evidence, the amount of translation and the level of reporting. Ask for a scoped quote after a short review of the patent, then compare it with the price of a licence or a damages claim.
Can anyone challenge a patent?
Often yes. An EPO opposition and a US ex parte reexamination request can be filed by third parties, and inter partes review is open to anyone except the patent owner, within its time limits. Rules differ by country.
Does a search that finds nothing mean the patent is valid?
No. It means no persuasive evidence turned up within the scope and budget of the search. That is still useful for risk assessment and licence talks.
